The Spiritual Diary of St. Paul of the Cross


St. Paul
of the Cross, the founder of the Passionist Priests and the Passionist Nuns, is not so well known these days. He is often confused with the Carmelite saint and doctor of the church, John of the Cross. St. Paul of the Cross, while sharing certain gifts with St. John of the Cross such as profound mystical knowledge of the spiritual life, is unique in his spirituality. The spiritual teaching and mysticism of St. Paul of the Cross is deeply centered on the Passion, death and Resurrection of Christ (which we call the Paschal Mystery) and also on our participation in the Sacraments of the Church (especially the Eucharist).

The Spiritual Diary of St. Paul of the Cross

St. Paul of the Cross’ writings are, perhaps, not as well known as some of the works of St. John of the Cross. However, the letters, poetry, and spiritual diary of St. Paul of the Cross contain a depth of wisdom, beauty, spiritual insight, and instruction for all who are seeking to deepen their relationship with Christ, who continues to reveal His deep love for us through His Holy Passion. St. Paul of the Cross teaches us how to learn from the Passion of Jesus and how to live that mystery (the Paschal Mystery) in our own lives as we open ourselves to the Holy Spirit.  

The Spiritual Diary of St. Paul of the Cross is a wonderful and practical source of learning how to do this in one’s prayer life. The diary is relatively short…no more than about 15 pages typed, but absolutely packed with depth.

 The Context of the Diary

St. Paul of the Cross wrote his Spiritual Diary during a 40-day solitude retreat which he made in December 1719 through January 1720 while staying in a small cell of St. Charles Church in Castelazzo, Italy. He went on this retreat at the request of his spiritual director and bishop for the purpose of clarifying the charism of the Passionist Congregation, which he had already been given permission to found. He was 26 years old at the time of this retreat, and on the verge of receiving the grace of mystical marriage. In other words, he was more spiritually advanced at this point in his life than most of us will ever be during our time here on earth! (Even though it is true that God calls all of us to this degree of union with Him, even in this life.)

The Difference Between a Diary and a Journal

Just for clarification, the Spiritual Diary is written in a style true to “diary-form.” It is not the same style as one might find in a spiritual “journal.” “What’s the difference?” you may ask. The difference is in St. Paul’s purpose and goal for writing. The dictionary definition of a “diary” is “a record of day-by-day notations in which successive events are experienced around an interior center.” In other words, a diary is more about keeping a practical record of events by daily notes. It is not so much about expressing one’s ideas, insights, and opinions (which would fall under the category of journaling.)

St. Paul’s Style of Writing in the Diary

In keeping with the practical nature of a true “diary”, the style with which St. Paul of the Cross writes is simple, straight-forward (or as straight-forward as one can be when describing very mysterious spiritual realities), and descriptive for the sake of pin-pointing the essence of his experiences at prayer. St. Paul of the Cross is writing his daily, true-to-life experiences as they happen. He keeps a record of them at the command of Bishop de Gattinara so that the work of God in his spirit can be better discerned.

How to Read the Diary

So how should a person read this great and somewhat secret spiritual work of writing? In the words of Stanislaus Breton, C.P., Ph. D., “the work must be read in the same spirit in which it was conceived”—namely, through a certain humble honesty and simplicity of spirit, contrary to what the extraordinary mysticism of St. Paul would seem to imply. I personally would also recommend that those who read it supplement their reading with a healthy dose of prayer and input from a competent spiritual guide.

                                                                                 

Eucharistic Devotion and the Graces of the 40-Day Retreat of St. Paul of the Cross

Sacramental Mysticism

What does it mean to be a mystic? In the dictionary, the word ‘mystical’ is defined as ‘hidden and mysterious.’ When we first hear the word “mystical” we might tend to think of floating in the air and seeing visions (experiences foreign to most of us!) Those experiences would, of course, fall under the category of mysticism. However, we are all called to share in the mystical life of grace just as we are all called to share in the life of Christ. And the life and grace of Christ are received through the sacraments of the Church.

Our spiritual life depends on and is nourished by the sacraments. The Eucharist is the primary source of grace for St. Paul—the center of his 40-day retreat. The mysticism of St. Paul of the Cross depends on the Eucharist, and the grace of the Passionist charism flows to Paul from the Eucharist, which makes the Passion & sacrifice of Jesus always present.

St. Paul of the Cross recognizes that the graces which he experiences flow from the Eucharist. Therefore, he pays special attention to what happens each day of the retreat during his Holy Communions. He often makes note in the diary of his spiritual experience before, during or after Holy Communion. He does this in 26 of his 34 diary entries. Holy Communion is, for Paul, a moment calling for reflection and attention—a moment that contains, in seed form, all the graces that he is to receive in a given day. In these moments of union with the Lord as “Sacramental Spouse,” his spirit is formed and transformed so that his daily living and praying becomes a continual communion with Christ. 

The Eucharist and Prayer

Throughout the Diary, Paul emphasizes his relationship with the Lord at Holy Communion and his relationship with the Lord at daily prayer. From the way Paul treats the two subjects in the Diary, he clearly understands that an intimate relationship exists between Holy Communion and prayer. In a mysterious way, the prayer of St. Paul (and, indeed, the mystical experiences of St. Paul at prayer) flows from the Eucharist. Prayer is the expression and extension of his living contact with Christ in the Eucharist.

The Eucharist and the Paschal Mystery

The Eucharist is the living memorial of the Passion of Jesus, through which the Person, love and sacrifice of Jesus is always present “until the end of time.” It is very appropriate that St. Paul’s deep communion with the Eucharistic Lord leads him to share in the spirit and life—indeed, the very heart—of the suffering and self-sacrificing Jesus. The same love that filled Jesus as He offered His Passion for love of us also filled the hart of St. Paul as he received the Eucahristic Jesus and spent time in His humble and hidden presence under the appearance of bread.

The Eucharist and the Passionist Charism

The Spirit and Life of Christ (the Holy Spirit), which animated and was poured forth from Jesus on the cross, is the source of the Passionist Charism. The Passionist Congregation itself is a “new creation” springing from the suffering and pierced Heart of Christ. From the water of the Sacraments of Baptism and Reconciliation and the Blood of the Sacrament of the Eucharist, there flows into the hearts of those called to the Passionist Congregation the Holy Trinity’s gift of the Passionist Charism.

It is in union with the Eucharistic Christ that Passionists live out their lives in the Church. “Eucharist” means thanksgiving. Passionists are to be “living sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving,” continually offering themselves, through, with and in Christ in the Holy Eucharist. They participate in the sacrificial offering of Christ for the sake of the praise and glory of the Father and that souls may receive His merciful love. It is Christ who offers Himself in them through the bond of the Holy Spirit, even as He also presents them as offerings of merciful love through, with and in Himself.


An excerpt from the Spiritual Diary of St. Paul of the Cross, Sunday, December 29th:

I had special recollection in offering his Most Holy Life, Death, and Passion, as also in my petitions, especially for heretics…because I want the standard of the holy faith to be erected so that there will be an increase of devotion and reverence, homage and love, with frequent acts of adoration for the Blessed Sacrament, the ineffable mystery of God’s most holy love, and so that his Holy Name may be glorified in a very special way.”

                                                                                                  

Prayer and Discernment of Spirits in the Spiritual Diary of Paul of the Cross

The Diary of St. Paul has great value for the intimate and honest attention given to his actual life of prayer. This “actual” life of prayer provides us with a broader spectrum of negative, positive, and even apathetic experiences at prayer, giving us true-to-life insight into the prayer life of a great saint and mystic. How much we would have missed in terms of spiritual instruction had he only highlighted certain ideal experiences at prayer! He writes the reality of what his prayer is.

Paul very clearly describes and records the details of very involved (and often intense) experiences at prayer, which unfold from His Eucharistic relationship with the Lord. He records everything from mystical graces to feeling cold or dry “like a stump.” He also writes about the tactics used by the devil to wage war on one who earnestly, fervently and consistently prays.

 

He writes about the different forces at work in his prayer:

1)      God and grace

* (Nov 26th) I feel my spirit can say no more and simply remains in God with his sufferings infused in my soul.

* (Dec 4th)  My dear God gave me infused knowledge of the joy the soul will have when we see him face to face, when in will be united with him in holy love

* (Dec 6th) These wonders cannot be explained with bodily comparisons because God makes them understood deep down in the soul with movements so spiritual that they cannot be explained; yet   they are grasped in an instant.

* (Dec 8th) My soul can say nothing more and fells itself melting away. I remain thus, languishing with great sweetness, mingled with tears, with the sufferings of my Spouse infused into my soul. Or to express it more clearly, the soul is immersed in the heart and in the sorrows of its beloved Spouse Jesus. Sometimes it understands them all and remains thus in God in this loving and sorrowful  contemplation. It is very difficult to explain and always seems to be something new.

 

2)      Self and nature

            Distractions from the senses

            * (Nov 25th) Seeing people, hearing them pass by, and the sound of the bells irritated me.

Distracting thoughts

*(Nov 29th) I would like to explain what happens in my distractions. When I am distracted, my soul remains at peace with God, neither more nor less, no matter how disturbing the thoughts may be that molest me. At night I say to my mind: “Go wherever you wish—here, there, everywhere—you will always go with God.” What happens in these distractions, not counting those that are clearly temptations, I really cannot say, except that they are of indifferent things, and sometimes they turn out to be thoughts of  spiritual things.   However,… I know my soul remains always rooted in God  and in his peace. But this is hidden and not evident to the senses, though the will is aware of this. It is the will which is the mouth and entry for the holy food of divine love. Even though it is fed silently, because of the hindrance from the memory and the intellect, which are lost in distractions, the will, nonetheless, remains attentive to its feeding on the love of God.”

Physical discomfort

*(Dec 10th) I was tempted to gluttony and seized with hunger. I felt the cold more than usual and my body wanted some relief, and on that account I wanted to flee from prayer. By the grace of God, my spirit held out, but the violence of the assaults kept coming from both my flesh and the devil.

Natural desires opposed to spiritual desires

*(Dec 15th -18th) I was dry, distracted with uneasiness and conflicts between the spirit and the flesh… The spirit, by the grace of God, wishes to subdue the flesh and make it stay submissive and obedient by uniting it to the understanding. The flesh, on the other hand, finds this hard to bear.  Therefore, when it feels hungry, it wants to eat; when it is weary from work or kneeling for a long time at prayer, it  wants to rest; when it is cold, it wants to be warmed; etc. On this account, I say, I have been very violently troubled by most of these things…

                                   

       Note: St. Paul of the Cross was called in a special way by God to practice extreme forms of penance. While we are all called to practice penance in some form, most of us are not called to the extreme forms practiced by St. Paul, such as extended and rigorous fasts, etc. Such extreme asceticism is not advisable   without the permission of a competent spiritual director. It is perfectly possible to practice good and effective penance while remaining a good steward to the body.

 

3)      The devil and temptation

            Desolation, impatience and anger   

*(Dec 21st )The Spirit kept resisting and wanted to remain with God in prayer, although felt  desolate and afflicted. The flesh, on the other hand, did not want to. On this account the passions were stirred up with intensity that my heart pounded and made me tremble from head to foot until my bones ached. I came to a point where I felt I could bear no more. Then the enemy appeared with temptations to impatience. He roused me to anger against the priests who were coming to say mass,  suggesting to me that they came too late. It seemed to me that I was being forced to make insulting remarks to them. At this point I called upon God and Mary to help me, and I kept saying to myself that I would stay there until all the Masses were said. This was to resist the temptation, for it seemed to me that I was being forced to leave.

Diabolic locutions

*When that was over, I felt assailed by temptations to the most frightful blasphemies against God. I seemed to hear myself interiorly repeating the most outrageous and appalling things; whereupon I called upon Mary to help me.

The devil is confounded because in this resistance put up by the soul and in these sufferings…the Sovereign Good is pleased, and the devil is mocked and put to flight.

 Thoughts about the future

*( Dec 23rd  ) I was buried in desolation and exteriorly disturbed about thoughts of the future, aroused by the devil. By the word “exteriorly” I meant that the thoughts come in this way.

*(Dec 30th) I was plagued with distractions, especially by thoughts of things in the future. The enemy represented to me that great tribulations would befall me, especially with regard to my family. I was also very downcast.  In all things may the Will of our God be done. Amen.

 

Because of his deep awareness of these different forces at work in his prayer, the Spiritual Diary of St. Paul of the Cross is an effective instruction manual on how to conduct oneself at prayer…

a)      when prayer is mysterious and difficult to understand in human terms

b)     when prayer is dry and an experience of spiritual poverty, and 

c)      when prayer is an experience of spiritual warfare.

 

St. Paul of the Cross provides an example of great wisdom in responding to experiences at prayer in a way that pleases God. He responds to difficulties and trials at prayer in a way that leads him to extend himself in charity for God and souls. Despite troubling and distracting thoughts, desires of the flesh, spiritual attacks and assaults, and temptations St. Paul returns to employing the will in order to remain lovingly faithful to his relationship with Christ Crucified in prayer. Paul exercises his will to love God by choosing to remain with God, even when prayer is dry or even unpleasant. His peace and strength at prayer lies in focusing on the loving will of God.

Excerpts from Nov 29th, Dec 10th and Dec 21st in the Diary:

“…in line with the understanding  that God gives me, and as I have come to realize, I know my soul remains always rooted in God and in his peace. But this is hidden and not evident to the senses, though the will is aware of this. It is the will which is the mouth and entry for the food of divine love.”

"Care must be taken not to withdraw from prayer at such a trying time because suffering would not be diminished thereby. On the contrary, without gain to itself the soul would be the more afflicted because it would see itself slipping into tepidity. However, I know that God makes me understand that the soul, which God wishes to draw to a high degree of union with himselfby means of prayer, must travel along this road of suffering in prayer—of suffering, I repeat, with out any sensible consolations…to him who overcomes will be given the hidden manna, which is what Sacred Scripture says. I understand “the hidden manna” to be the sweet food of holy love, that is, the soul resting in deepest repose with its beloved Spouse in prayer.”

 “I would like to make everyone understand the grace that God, in his mercy, bestows when he sends suffering, especially suffering devoid of consolation. Then the soul is purified like gold in the furnace. Without knowing, it becomes radiant and is set free to take flight to its Good, that is, to the blessed transformation. It carries the cross of Jesus and it knows it not. This arises from the number and variety of sufferings which make it forget everything and no longer remember that it is suffering. I understand that this is a great and fruitful way of suffering, most pleasing to God, because the soul thereby becomes indifferent to such an extent that it no longer thinks of sorrow or joy, but solely of remaining conformed to the Holy Will of its beloved Spouse Jesus.”

Now the devil, envious of this high state of the soul at prayer, seeing that he cannot snatch it from the infinite grasp of the Immense Divinity, attempts, nevertheless, to disturb it to some degree. He assails it with temptations, or else with vain imaginings, or with different kinds of thoughts, or again, the better to deceive it, with his infamous lies. He does all this to distract it from deep attentiveness to God…

                                                                   

The Passionist Charism in the Spiritual Diary of St. Paul of the Cross: desire and inspiration

 “And they shall look on him whom they have thrust through, and they shall mourn for him as one mourns for an only son, and they shall grieve over him as one grieves over a firstborn..”—Zechariah 12:10b

Drawing its spirit from the suffering, sorrowful and merciful love of Christ, it is the special charism of the Passionist Congregation to return and to share in this particular love by their spirit of compassionate mourning for Jesus. Not only are they called to love Christ in His Suffering, but they are called to share in the mission of Christ by promoting the Passion of Jesus and striving by prayer and sacrifice to bring its fruits of grace into the souls of all.

Desires of St. Paul of the Cross During His Retreat

During the 40-day retreat of St. Paul of the Cross, the Passionist Charism – a particular gift of the spirit—begins to emerge with greater intensity and clarity. Where do we look to see it? One of the best places to look is at the desires animating St. Paul of the Cross as he writes his Spiritual Diary during the time of his 40-day retreat. Among these desires are the desire for communion with the suffering, crucified Christ, desire for Holy Communion, desire to console and be present to the crucified Jesus, desire for martyrdom, desire for the conversion of sinners, desire to make reparation to God for sins against the Holy Eucharist, and finally, the desire that God be glorified and loved by all. In this case, these inspired desires of St. Paul express a call from God, emerging at this point with greater clarity—the fruit of prayer and Communion with the Eucharistic Lord. This call is to be answered by St. Paul and his spiritual children in the foundation of the Passionist Congregation and in the living of Passionist life.


Four-Fold Spirit

With this call to suffer with and mourn for Christ in order to bring the graces of Jesus’ Passion to sinners, the Holy Spirit is inspiring St. Paul to also actively seek to be united with the Suffering Christ by particular means. This “means” is contained in the four-fold spirit of the Passionist Charism, which includes poverty, prayer, solitude and penance.

Poverty

Throughout his 40-day retreat, St. Paul of the Cross experiences the great heights of the love of God in poverty of spirit. He finds himself in awe of the perfection of love, which strengthens and impassions his soul particularly in his experiences of freely accepted deprivation of material and physical comfort, the darkness of faith, temptations of the flesh (nature) and the devil, spiritual dryness, etc. And in this poverty, which is most deeply experienced in poverty of spirit,” St. Paul “desires no relief.” He desires that they continue, according to the good pleasure of God, because in them he finds deeper and more profound union to the beloved Crucified Jesus, Who emptied Himself unto death.

(Excerpts from the Diary, Monday, November 25th and Saturday, November 30th)

“I was without sensible feeling at prayer, even distracted…I was filled with affliction and melancholy—also tempted with compassion toward my family. Seeing people, hearing them pass by, and the sound of the bells irritated me. In short, I seemed to have a heart that was buried without any feeling of prayer. Nevertheless, I had no desire for relief, and in my mind I was content to have troubles. But this contentment is not felt, for at such a time there is anguish of a special kind. There is a certain contentment that the most Holy Will of our dear God is fulfilled.”

“I asked Jesus to make me humble in a supreme degree. I wished to be the lowest of humankind, the dregs of the earth, and I prayed the Blessed Virgin to intercede for this grace…the soul that humbles itself beneath hell itself makes the demon tremble and defeats him, and the Sovereign Good raises that soul to paradise. I know that everything comes from my God.”

 

Solitude

The 40-day retreat of St. Paul of the Cross takes place in the solitude of a small and poorly furnished cell in St. Charles Church. However, more than a solitude consisting of physical spaces, the most penetrating solitude is experienced by St. Paul in the depths of his spirit. In this solitude, St Paul’s spirit “simply remains in God with his sufferings infused in his soul.” His diary entries are marked consistently by experiences of desolation (spiritual, and non-spiritual) and “abandonment.” And these are suffered with peace, trust, and abandonment to the Holy Will of God. Paul’s peace and spiritual joy in this solitude are derived from his awareness of their being a means of deepening his union to Christ, who agonized in the solitude of a garden and suffered abandonment by so many of His friends during His Passion.

(Excerpt from the Diary, Tuesday, November 26th)

“I feel my spirit can say no more and simply remains in God with his sufferings infused in my soul. At other times it seems my heart is shattered… I was particularly afflicted and melancholy…Although this sadness did not take away my peace of heart, I felt great affliction since I had no spiritual consolation or any other. It seemed rather that I never had any… his crosses are the joy of my heart.”

 (Excerpt from the Diary Tuesday, Dec 3rd)

“I seem to be buried in the depth of misery, to be the most desolate and wretched of men. Nevertheless, my soul embraces them, for I know this is the Will of God and that they are the joys of Jesus.”

 

 Prayer

As the agonizing prayer of Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane, the prayer of Paul of the Cross during the 40-day retreat is often a prayer of suffering, spiritual warfare, agony and intercession. Paul’s sufferings at prayer are approached with a disposition like that of Jesus in the Garden—generous and courageous humility coupled with loving and obedient abandonment to the will of the Father. His prayer thus becomes a participation in the Passion of Jesus, and therefore a means to deeper union with Christ, Who in the hour of His great distress prayed earnestly. In the Diary Paul writes of intense sufferings particularly in prayer. It is interesting to note that he devotes his longest, most articulate and descriptive writing to his experiences of dryness and distraction at prayer. He does not spend half as much time, detail, or emphasis on extraordinary mystical experiences. This is probably because his mystical experiences are not as easy for the mind to put into words. However, I like to think that this is also because ordinary sufferings at prayer are more well-known to us all, and we need instruction on how to deal with them virtuously.

(Excerpt from Tuesday, Dec 10th – Friday, December 13th)

“I was dry, distracted, and tempted. I had to force myself to stay at prayer…my body wanted some relief, and on that account I wanted to flee from prayer. By the grace of God, my spirit held out, but the violence of the assaults kept coming from both the flesh and the devil…I know this kind of prayer of suffering is a great gift, which God grants the soul to make it a spotless robe of purity, a rock in the face of suffering, to such a point that it no longer takes any account of it. When by God’s grace the soul reaches such a state, the Sovereign Good will inflame it with love. Care must be taken not to withdraw from prayer at such a trying time because suffering would not be diminished thereby. On the contrary, without gain to itself the soul would be the more afflicted because it would see itself slipping into tepidity. However, I know that God makes me understand that the soul, which God wishes to draw to a high degree of union with himself by means of prayer, must travel along the road of suffering in prayer—of suffering, I repeat, without any sensible consolations so that the soul no longer knows where it is, so to speak, but has the deep infused knowledge which God gives it, that it is ever in the arms of its Spouse and is nourished by his infinite charity.”

 (Excerpt from Friday, Nov 29th)

“…was dry and distracted in prayer…I know my soul remains always rooted in God and in His peace. But this is hidden and not evident to the senses, though the will is aware of this. It is the will which is the mouth and entry for the holy food of divine love. Even though it is fed silently, because of the hindrance from memory and intellect, which are lost in distractions, the will, nonetheless, remains attentive to its feeding on the love of God. At most, it does not relish the situation as much as when the powers of the intellect and memory are at one with it.”

(Excerpt from Monday, Dec 23rd)

“Now the devil, envious of this high state of the soul at prayer, seeing that he cannot snatch it from the infinite grasp of the Immense Divinity, attempts, nevertheless to disturb it to some degree. He assails it with temptations, or else with vain imaginings, or with different kinds of thoughts, or again, the better to deceive it, with his infamous lies. He does all this to distract it from deep attentiveness to God… In fighting these attacks and repulsing them, the soul may appear to be at a disadvantage because it loses a little of its loving attentiveness and seems to be no longer in the embrace of its beloved Spouse. But God makes me understand that the soul is with him and that he is pleased to see it thus engaged in battle. This is more profitable for the soul since, as a result of what it suffers and endures in the struggle, it is purified like the rock, which before the storm may have been covered with debris, but after the storm is cleansed because the waves have washed it clean. A word of warning is necessary here. When these storms of troublesome thoughts arise, one must remain fixed in God without taking any notice of them. When the enemy sees that he gains nothing thereby, he is put to shameful flight, perceiving that by God’s help he is not feared.”

(Excerpt from Saturday, Dec 21st)

“The spirit, by the grace of God, wishes to subdue the flesh and make it stay submissive and obedient by uniting it to the understanding [will]. The flesh, on the other hand, finds this hard to bear. Therefore, when it feels hungry, it wants to eat; when it is weary from work or kneeling a long time at prayer, it wants to rest; when it is cold, it wants to be warmed; etc. On this account, I say, I have been very violently troubled by most of these things on this particular day. The spirit kept resisting and wanted to remain with God in prayer, although it felt desolate and afflicted. The flesh, on the other hand, did not want to. On this account the passions were stirred up with such intensity…Then the enemy appeared with temptations to impatience… It is true, that although the soul is in great distress, these dreadful temptations against God disappear in a flash, and the Sovereign Good does not allow the poor soul to remain beset by them

 

Penance

From Chapter IV of the Revised Constitutions of the Passionist Nuns:

"Christ calls all to conversion and penance, inviting them to take up their cross daily and to follow Him. The Passionist Nuns respond to this urgent call as they also bear in mind the mystery of Christ’s Passion. They consider it “a great grace from God to love penance”, so that they may better “fill up what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ, for the sake of His Body, the Church.

In the communal and individual practice of conversion and penance, the nuns keep in mind that austerity is not sought for its own sake, but is rather an expression of their obedient and joyful love for Christ and for His church. The value of their penance does not depend so much on its rigor as on its open and peaceful firmness, and the affability and gentleness which permeate it.

For the love of Christ, they generously embrace as their first work of conversion and penance the difficulties of daily life, together with “the practice of solid virtue, the imitation of Jesus Christ, the observance of the Rule, loving to be unknown, having equal love for all, doing God’s Will in everything”. They spontaneously and joyfully give themselves to the various kinds of work required in the monastery. They accept patiently any form of suffering that comes with life itself, such as sickness and advancing age ."

 

St Paul of the Cross’ Penance during the 40 Day Retreat

The penance and mortification practiced by St. Paul during the 40-day retreat was severe—intense fasting, being without heat during some of the coldest months of the year, kneeling for long hours at a time, and more. Clearly, most of us (even fellow Passionists) are not called to follow St. Paul of the Cross in the rigorous physical penances he was called to practice.   Rather than imitating Paul of the Cross in the exact forms of penance he practiced, we can learn from the spirit with which St. Paul carries out penances.

 

St. Paul of the Cross’ Spirit When Offering Penance

The spirit that animates Paul in penances and sufferings is one of love, generosity in response to God’s invitations, and spiritual joy. We know that this is what makes them pleasing and fruitful offerings to God. What is most important is that Paul accepts and embraces his sufferings as penances chosen for Him by a wise and loving God. Through faith and docile, trusting, and loving obedience to God, Paul’s heart is free and loving in his penances and sufferings. The key to understanding Paul’s penance and his spirit toward suffering is love. Paul’s focus during penances and sufferings in the diary is on God and others with an emphasis on communion with the will of the loving God and compassion.

Love for God

Paul’s penances are clearly an overflowing gift of self in response to Christ’s sacrificial gift of self. Paul’s penances are inspired and embraced out of desire for intimate union with Christ, who obediently sacrificed himself for the sake of others. It is the spirit of self-sacrifice that leads into communion with the holocaust offering of Jesus for the praise and glory of the Father and for the salvation of souls.

Love for Souls

Throughout his retreat, Paul shows through his writing that he has a fervent love for souls and desires that all experience the fruit of the Passion of Jesus, which is salvation. He experiences sorrow considering that souls are lost. He knows that penance is the way prescribed by God for us to help bring the fruits of the Passion of Jesus to these souls.

St. Paul of the Cross is joyfully willing (and even desiring) to offer penance because of His compassionate love for Jesus and souls-- so much so that at some points during his retreat, penance is sweet.

Notice Paul’s desires experienced in moments of sweetness and also in moments of trial:

(From Wednesday, November 27th in the Diary)

Sweetness:“…I had such great joy and desire of suffering that the cold, the snow, and the ice all seemed sweet to me, and I desired to experience them with great fervor as I said to Jesus: “Your pains, my dear God, are the pledges of your love.”

(From Wednesday, Dec 4th)

Sweetness: “I felt sorrow in seeing him offended, and I told him that I would willingly be torn to pieces for a single soul. Indeed, I felt that I would die when I saw the loss of so many souls who do not experience the fruit of the Passion of my Jesus.”

(From Friday, Dec 6th)

Peace tranquility and intense love: “I was especially fervent in praying for sinners and for God to hasten to found this Congregation in the holy Church. I had a keen infused knowledge of the sufferings of my Jesus, and I felt so ardent a desire to be perfectly united with him that I wished to actually feel his sufferings and to be with him on the cross.”

(From Saturday, Dec 21st)

Trials: “The spirit, by the grace of God, wishes to subdue the flesh and make it stay submissive and obedient by uniting it to the understanding [will]. The flesh, on the other hand, finds this hard to bear. Therefore, when it feels hungry, it wants to eat; when it is weary from work or kneeling a long time at prayer, it wants to rest; when it is cold, it wants to be warmed; etc. On this account, I say, I have been very violently troubled by most of these things on this particular day. The spirit kept resisting and wanted to remain with God in prayer, although it felt desolate and afflicted. The flesh, on the other hand, did not want to."

On this account the passions were stirred up with such intensity…Then the enemy appeared with temptations…

In the secret depths of the heart, there is a certain hidden and almost imperceptible desire to always be immersed in sufferings of one kind or another.

… I know that the glory of God shines forth therein and that the devil is confounded because in this resistance put up by the soul and in these sufferings—according to the understanding God gives me—the Sovereign Good is pleased, and the devil is mocked and put to flight. I know, too, that God holds the soul in his embrace, although the soul, not realizing this, seems to be utterly abandoned in its overwhelming misery, and this is all mixed up in some way with the attacks I have referred to…

“When I am in this state… I desire it in order to suffer, and I have a certain fear that it will depart except, of course, those temptations against God…The fear I mention arises from the soul’s longing to follow Jesus in suffering. The profit which the soul gains form this can never be over-estimated; but it does not seek this, for love seeks not its own advantage, but only the glory of the Sovereign Good…

“Although it is true that sometimes my soul is troubled for fear of losing its sufferings, I am never so troubled as to lose peace of heart on this account.

“I would like to make everyone understand the great grace that God, in his mercy, bestows when he sends suffering, especially suffering devoid of consolation.”“I understand that this is a great and fruitful way of suffering, most pleasing to God, because the soul thereby becomes indifferent to such an extent that it no longer thinks of sorrow or joy, but solely of remaining conformed to the Holy Will of its beloved Spouse Jesus.

It desires above all else, to be crucified with him, because in this it is more conformable to its beloved God, who during his whole life did nothing but suffer.”

 

Loving Penance as a Path to Freedom and Joy and Peace

St. Paul is an instructor on how to find communion with Jesus Crucified, and also spiritual joy precisely through penance and sufferings. This communion and spiritual joy are the fruits of love. St. Paul teaches us through his example that through our penances and crosses, we are invited to the deepest and richest spiritual joy and freedom— Joy and freedom in loving. Of course, apart from faith, hope and love, there is no joy or freedom to be found in penance or sufferings.

We do not simply desire penance and the pain of the cross for its own sake. If so, what is good about it? The hidden treasure buried in penance and suffering is discovered by faith.  What is the hidden treasure?

-Love stronger than death.

-The objective evil of pain and hardship transformed (through this love) into grace and mercy.

-Unshakeable peace that comes from within (from the Holy Spirit in us).

-Inner freedom despite circumstances not of our choosing, which are objectively undesirable.

-Patience that is otherwise unattainable.

Much more!  

 

Through his sufferings, St. Paul of the Cross finds communion with Jesus and a means (through faith) of bringing other souls to faith in God and love for Christ. This communion and this faith-knowledge, in turn, enables him to suffer with love and joy. Clearly, he understands the value of penance and sufferings offered in love.

  

Summary

By living lives of poverty, solitude, prayer and penance, the Passionists unite themselves to the saving sacrifice of love offered for all by Christ on Calvary. By means of this four-fold spirit, faithfully lived, the Passionists become living sacrifices of praise to the glory of God the Father, and for the salvation of souls. In this way, we die to ourselves so that Christ may live in us, making His Passion present in the world through our lives of love and sacrifice. As exemplified by St. Paul of the Cross during his retreat, it is not that poverty, solitude, prayer and penance have power in themselves to produce this union with Christ. Rather, the great charity, which has been poured out into the heart of St. Paul and the Passionists through the Holy Spirit (Rom 5:5) will draw the soul of one gifted with the Passionist charism to give expression to this charity by means of poverty, solitude, prayer and penance.

 


 Home  Novitiate Corner  Sr Rose Marie